Do the words at Zechariah 1:7, 12 indicate that by 519 B.C.E. the seventy years of desolation had not yet been fulfilled? If so, might this suggest that the seventy-year period began in or around 589 B.C.E.?
At Zechariah 1:7 we read:
Using 539 B.C.E. as a pivotal date establishes the "twenty-fourth day of the eleventh month" of the "second year of Darius" as February 9, 519 B.C.E. on the Gregorian calendar. It should be noted that the Darius spoken of at Zechariah 1:7 is the Persian king Darius I (also known as Darius the Great, or Darius Hystaspes), and not Darius the Mede ("the son of Ahasuerus of the seed of the Medes."—Daniel 9:1) who took administrative control of Babylon following its conquest by Cyrus the Great.
Zechariah continues in verse 12:
From the angel's use of the words "these seventy years" (New World Translation), it might appear to some that toward the conclusion of the seventy years the angel is asking Jehovah how much longer Jerusalem must lie desolate. (Compare with "those seventy years" as used by the following translations: Amplified Bible, Living Bible, King James Version, Modern King James Version, Darby Version, and Green's Literal Translation.) Those who recognize and admit that the Biblical evidence indicates that the seventy years of desolation commenced after the destruction of Jerusalem, but who are unable to reconcile the twenty or so missing years (according to presently-accepted secular chronology), have advanced the theory that the "seventy years" ran up to the completion of the reconstructed temple in Jerusalem. Somehow, they reason that up until this time the land of Judah was still considered "desolate."
This, of course, was not the case. At Jeremiah 29:10, Jehovah reassured the Jewish exiles that after seventy (not forty-eight or fifty) years had been fulfilled at Babylon, they would be permitted to return to their homeland:
The Bible elsewhere reports that the seventy years ran "until the royalty of Persia began to reign" (2 Chronicles 36:20). Cyrus' decree, made in "the first year of Cyrus the king of Persia," (Ezra 1:1-4) or 538/7 B.C.E., released the Jews from servitude to Babylon, permitting them to return to Judah to rebuild their cities. Thus, in 537 B.C.E., a total of 49,897 Jews made the expedition back to their homeland (Ezra 2:64), and "when the seventh month arrived the sons of Israel were in [their] cities."—Ezra 3:1.
Yes, the fact that the Persian king Darius I is ruling at this time, as stated in Zechariah 1:7, establishes that the seventy years ended as much as twenty years earlier, when, in the first year of Darius the Mede, Daniel correctly discerned that their completion was approaching.—Daniel 9:2.
To suggest that the seventy year period ran from 589 B.C.E. to 519 B.C.E. (or 587/6 B.C.E. to 516 B.C.E.), whether speaking in terms of servitude or desolation, or both, is completely without foundation, and contradicts both Scripture and well-established history. This subject is discussed further, with details as to what the angel was speaking of, in Chapter 8: Mercy to the Persecuted But Judgment to the Persecutors of the Watchtower Society publication Paradise Restored To Mankind – By Theocracy!, pp. 130-3).
Next article: Cyrus conquered Babylon in 539 B.C.E., but the Jewish captives did not return to their homeland until 537 B.C.E. Therefore, how could it be said that the Jews served "the king of Babylon" for seventy years if the king of Babylon was conquered two years earlier?
Last revised: 97/11/09. Copyright © 1997 by Jehovah's Witnesses—Setting the Record Straight. All rights reserved. This web site is not affiliated with or sanctioned by the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. However, every effort has been made to adhere to the current views published by the "faithful and discreet slave" (Matthew 24:45; Luke 12:42) through the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. The "Official Web Site of Jehovah's Witnesses" can be found at http://www.jw.org, and should be recognized as the authoritative source about the beliefs, teachings, and activities of Jehovah's Witnesses.